A Thought Experiment

posted Friday, 21 March 2008

Today, around the world, many folks commemorate the torture and execution of an alleged criminal at the hands of functionaries of the Roman empire. I wonder if, two thousand years from now, anyone will commemorate someone else's torture and death--perhaps in Gitmo some poor soul is biding his time 'til his apotheosis. Should it happen, I suppose there's a fair chance that blame could even be shifted away from the American empire, rather the way that church history exculpated their own empire. He was turned in, say, by his own people on trumped up charges and George W. Bush did everything he could to wash his hands of the matter. It's a strange exercise to think how we might figure into someone else's mythology, as I'm sure it would have been for people living two thousand years ago. It seems like it would be harder to make good mythology now though, since we have so much better documentation and a much clearer understanding of evidence and, well, how the world works. If Saddam Hussein, for instance, was rumored to have risen from the dead, I suspect we'd all be more than a little skeptical, figuring that either the now-living Hussein is an imposture or that the death itself was faked. Of course, I guess with well over six billion of us, there would be people who'd be willing to buy into it, but they'd be such a minority that it would be inconceivable to think it could rise to be the world's dominant religion. I mean it would probably take a near-total collapse of civilization as we know it to allow such a mythology to arise and come to the sort of prominence that the other great popular mythologies have managed. Hmmm.

Well, don't mind me. I'm headed off in a few hours to sing in a Good Friday service. 

links: digg this    del.icio.us    technorati    reddit




1. Sarah left...
Friday, 21 March 2008 5:22 pm

Occam's Razon--if two explanations (or more) exist, one easy to follow and having multiple previous examples to point to, and another (others) more fanciful, convoluted, abstruse, mythological, the investigator is to choose the former.

Which makes more sense: Jesus wasn't dead and revived in the cave and his followers whisked him away to recover (so the women found the tomb empty), or that he was raised from the dead to sit on the right hand of the mythical Sky Being and sit in judgment of us all?

Hmmmm....have to think that one over.


2. Nutsy Fagan left...
Friday, 21 March 2008 5:28 pm

I could get into trouble here....so I'm just going to wish everyone and happe Easter.


3. Nutsy Fagan left...
Friday, 21 March 2008 5:30 pm

Oops. I meant Happy Easter. :)


4. Mary Blu left...
Saturday, 22 March 2008 8:46 am :: http://mindtravels.wordpress.com/

Happy Easter John!


5. sophmom left...
Saturday, 22 March 2008 9:48 pm :: http://www.dotcalm.blog-city.com

Okay, I'm gonna jump in all contrarian to say that the whole point is to demonstrate love. God (and not that Flying Spaghetti Monster God but the universal unifying force God) saying to us, "You dumbasses, stop hating each other and being all competitive and trying to be so damn right all the time. Oh, here, I'll freakin' show you since you're too thick to figure it out yourselves. I'll just have to become you, to be born like you and die like you. That's what love is."

That's what he talked about while he was here. Are the folks in Gitmo talking like that? For all we know, they might be.

Oh, well, Happy Easter anyway, y'all. :)


6. catty left...
Monday, 24 March 2008 5:55 am :: http://savetheamericanfamily.blog-city.c

Happy belated Easter! I hope you ate yummy food.

As to future mythologies, look at all the conspiracy theories surrounding 911. Even though evidence and common sense indicates an attack by foreign hijackers, there are still those who say it was the US government behind it. Stranger things have happened.